Last Updated on April 13, 2023 by brewthatcoffee
If you’re not a fan of Starbucks toffee nut syrup, it’s clear that you have yet to try it! Perhaps you missed it during the fall or winter holidays. One thing is certain: Starbucks toffee nut syrup can take the most ordinary drink to the next level, and it’s addictive! Whether from the regular menu or the secret one, toffee nut drinks from Starbucks should be on everyone’s bucket list.
Here are the 15 best Starbucks toffee nut drinks, ranked from worst to best:
15. Oleato Iced Shaken Espresso with Oat Milk And Toffee Nut
14. Coconut Cream Pie Frappuccino
13. Nutter Butter Frappuccino
12. Salted Caramel Mocha Frappuccino
11. Hot Butterbeer Latte
10. Toffee Nut Chai Tea Latte
9. And more…
What Is Toffee Nut At Starbucks?
Toffee nut is a syrup that Starbucks uses to sweeten and flavor some of its drinks, like coffees, mochas, frappuccinos, desserts, and more. It is a sweet caramel syrup with a consistency similar to honey, although it’s less sticky.
To make a toffee nut syrup, you would combine butter, toasted nuts, and caramelized sugar. Then, simmer it in a saucepan until it becomes a thick, golden syrup. That’s if you were going to make it yourself.
But most people will take the shortcut and head to Starbucks for their instant toffee nut fix or find a place to buy the syrup to make their own decadent beverages at home.
What Does Toffee Nut Taste Like?
Toffee nut is a sweet and rich flavor that tastes somewhat like butterscotch. Aside from the sweetness, it has undertones of brown butter, toasted nuts, and toffee. No wonder it’s called toffee nut!
Toffee is a traditional sweet made by boiling butter, sugar, and milk until the mixture becomes thick and syrupy. When the syrup reaches a specific temperature, the confectioner pours it onto parchment paper to harden.
The nutty flavor of the syrup is reminiscent of macadamias, almonds, or hazelnuts. Talking about it probably makes you taste that childhood toffee flavor in your mouth!
You might be salivating for a toffee nut drink now, but what about your nut allergy? The good news is that Starbucks uses nut flavorings but no peanuts or tree nuts. This means that all nut-flavored syrups are safe for those with allergies.
Calories And Sugar In Toffee Nut Syrup
According to the Starbucks website, one pump of toffee nut syrup has 20 calories and 5 grams of sugar. This is the same amount as their other flavored syrups, such as vanilla, caramel, or hazelnut.
But keep in mind that most drinks have more than one pump of syrup, and it varies according to the drink size and customization. For example, a grande (16 oz) salted caramel mocha has four pumps of mocha sauce and four pumps of toffee nut syrup, which adds up to 160 calories and 40 grams of sugar from the syrups alone.
Where Can I Buy Starbucks Toffee Nut Syrup/Creamer?
If you can’t wait to get to Starbucks to enjoy your toffee nut drinks, you will be thrilled to know that you can buy the syrup via online retailers, such as Amazon, at retail stores like Wal-Mart and Target, and Starbucks stores or their website. You can also find it in some grocery stores or specialty coffee shops.
Another option is to buy the Starbucks Toffee Nut Creamer, a dairy-based product containing cream and flavoring. You can use it instead of milk or cream in your coffee or tea. You can also find it in some grocery stores and online.
Syrups That Pair Well With Toffee Nut
Toffee nut is a versatile flavor that can be paired with many hot and cold drinks at Starbucks and many different syrups. On its own, it goes down well in coffees (hot and cold), lattes, mochas, frappuccinos, and hot chocolates, to mention a few.
The toffee nut syrup goes down a treat with other syrups because of its rich, sweet, buttery, and nutty flavor. Here are some examples:
- Caramel and toffee nut: This classic pairing creates a rich and decadent drink. Try adding both syrups to your latte or cappuccino for a caramel macchiato-like experience.
- Mocha and toffee nut: This popular pairing adds a chocolatey twist to your drink. Together in a coffee or espresso, they create a dreamy salted-caramel mocha treat.
- Vanilla and toffee nut: This combination gives your drink a smooth and creamy tone and works particularly well in an iced coffee or cold brew.
- Hazelnut and toffee nut: The hazelnut syrup adds an extra nuttiness to the delicious toffee flavor. Use the combination in your hot chocolate or chai tea for a cozy winter drink.
- Cinnamon Dolce and toffee nut: These syrups pair well, adding warmth and spice to an apple cider or pumpkin latte during the festive season.
15 Best Starbucks Toffee Nut Drinks Ranked
Toffee nut is a delicious flavor that adds a sweet and nutty taste to your Starbucks drinks. The coffee chain produces many toffee nut drinks from the regular menu in season and the secret menu at any time of the year.
If you’ve just discovered the toffee nut syrup, you will want to pay attention to the secret menu recipes with this flavor so you can order it whenever the craving comes upon you.
Perhaps you’re not sure what the secret menu is about. It’s not an actual menu; it refers to drinks that customers create by customizing those from the regular menu. Because there are so many, you can’t simply ask the barista for a secret drink by name. You have to give them the recipe to create your preferred fantasy drink.
You would start by ordering the base drink (the regular menu drink) and tell the barista which milk, syrups, toppings, and how many shots to add, if applicable. There are tens of thousands of secret drinks, so unless your local store barista has had numerous orders for the same thing, he will need specific instructions to get your drink right. So be specific, be patient, and be polite!
If you’re a Starbucks toffee nut fan, in all likelihood, you’re a sweet tooth. With this in mind, when we rank the drinks from worst to best, we do not imply the drinks at the beginning of the list are terrible. Instead, it’s a case of which toffee nut drink wears the crown amongst all the favorites.
15. Oleato Iced Shaken Espresso With Oat Milk and Toffee Nut
Starbucks has recently launched a range of olive oil-infused hot and cold coffees known as Oleato, courtesy of the outgoing interim CEO of the company, Howard Schultz. Schultz got the idea of mixing olive oil and coffee when he learned that some Italians take a spoonful of olive oil daily for health reasons. He decided to do both in his morning coffee.
The olive oil-infused coffee has a delightfully buttery and velvety flavor and texture that lingers pleasantly on the palate. The Oleato Iced Shaken Espresso with oat milk and toffee nut is a regular menu item and consists of the following:
- 3 shots of Blonde Espresso Roast
- oat milk
- 4 pumps of toffee nut syrup.
Nutritional Information (grande): 250 calories, 12g sugar, 255mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: If you’re not an oat milk lover, ask for the milk of your choice, as Starbucks carries several plant milk options, along with dairy choices.
14. Coconut Cream Pie Frappuccino
This dreamy coconut dessert is a secret menu treat with both a winter and a summer version! When the seasonal coconut ingredients are available in-store, ordering the Coconut Cream Pie Frappuccino is simple. But there’s a variation that you can use all year round by using coconut milk to create a similarly delicious drink.
The summer version has a stronger coconut flavor due to the Coconut Crème Frappuccino ingredients. As those ingredients are out of season for the rest of the year, the year-round drink will have a lighter coconut taste. The toffee nut and hazelnut syrups are reminiscent of a sweet and nutty pie crust. Close your eyes, and you will have a coconut cream pie in a cup.
To make the year-round Coconut Cream Pie Frappuccino, ask the barista for:
- Vanilla Bean Frappuccino, a blend of milk, ice, and vanilla bean powder
- Ask for coconut milk
- Hazelnut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, and 2 for venti)
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, and 2 for venti)
- Add whipped cream and caramel drizzle, if desired
For the summer Coconut Cream Pie Frappuccino, ask for the following:
- Coconut Crème Frappuccino, a blend of whole milk, coconut syrup, Frappuccino base, and ice
- Hazelnut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, and 2 for venti)
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, and 2 for venti)
- Top with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and toasted coconut flakes
Nutritional Information (Venti): 470 calories, 68g sugar, 0mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: If you still need a caffeine kick, ask the barista for the number of espresso shots you want and your preferred roast. You can also increase or decrease the amount of vanilla bean powder in the beverage.
13. Nutter Butter Frappuccino
The Nutter Butter sandwich cookies were the inspiration for this Frappuccino. This secret menu beverage may not be a health nut’s first choice, but it contains a banana, so it will be filling and could pass as a meal replacement. Yes, it is grasping at straws to find an excuse for breaking your diet, but sometimes you have to give in to the craving and justify it somehow!
This Frappuccino is sweet, creamy, nutty, and buttery, with mild coffee undertones, perfect for a lazy spring afternoon.
To order a Nutter Butter Frappuccino, ask your barista nicely for the following:
- Hazelnut Frappuccino, which consists of milk, coffee, ice, and hazelnut syrup
- Toffee nut syrup (2 pumps for a grande, 3 for a venti)
- Cinnamon Dolce syrup (2 pumps grande, 3 for a venti)
- A whole banana blended
- Whipped cream on top
Nutritional Information (Tall): 160 calories, 31g sugar, 65mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: You can choose your type of milk for all beverages at Starbucks and ask for extra espresso shots if you need some energy.
12. Salted Caramel Mocha Frappuccino
The Salted Caramel Mocha Frappuccino is a treat from the Starbucks regular menu, so you can order it anytime without memorizing the recipe. Regular doesn’t mean boring, though. The combination of salted caramel and mocha must be one of the paths to Heaven!
What goes into one of these heavenly treats? Each Salted Caramel Mocha Frappuccino contains the following:
- Whole milk blended with ice and coffee
- 2 pumps toffee nut syrup
- 2 pumps Mocha sauce
- Sweetened whipped cream
- Topped with caramel sauce and a crunchy mix of turbinado sugar and sea salt
Nutritional Information (Grande): 420 calories, 63g sugar, 100mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: If dairy products are not for you, choose oat, almond, or soya milk instead. To add some crunch, ask for some Frappuccino chips.
11. Hot Butterbeer Latte
If you’re a die-hard Harry Potter fan, you will be familiar with Butterbeer. It was made from butterscotch, water, and sugar and tasted “a little bit like less-sickly butterscotch.” The Hogwarts inhabitants could buy Butterbeer at Three Broomsticks Inn, Hog’s Head Inn, and the Leaky Cauldron.
Though sweet, Starbucks Hot Butterbeer Latte is not sickly, nor do you have to travel to Hogwarts to get this beverage. It is deliciously creamy and tastes like butterscotch, with the cinnamon giving a slightly spicy flavor.
It’s a perfect fall secret menu drink, especially when having a Harry Potter movie marathon night. Pick up your beverage just before you start the movie marathon. Here’s how to order it:
- Ask for a whole milk steamer
- Caramel syrup (2 pumps for tall, 3 for grande, 4 for venti)
- Toffee nut syrup (2 pumps for tall, 3 for grande, 4 for venti)
- Cinnamon Doce syrup (2 pumps for tall, 3 for grande, 4 for venti)
- Whipped cream topped with salted caramel bits
Nutritional Information (Grande): 380 calories, 47g sugar, 0mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: If you need a caffeine boost, ask the barista to add 1-2 espresso shots. Substitute your preferred milk and decrease the pumps of syrup slightly to lower the drink’s calories.
10. Toffee Nut Chai Tea Latte
Chai tea is a warm and comforting beverage with a black tea base combined with spices like cinnamon, cardamom, and cloves. In its purest form, it’s a very healthy beverage rich in antioxidants, excellent for your heart and skin, reduces inflammation, and does many other wonderful things for the body.
A Starbucks Toffee Nut Chai Tea Latte might still have those healthy characteristics buried deep inside, but essentially it is a sweet and spicy comfort drink you will enjoy any time of the year. It is a secret menu drink but is not difficult to order.
- Ask for a venti chai tea latte
- Make it with oat milk
- Add 2 pumps of toffee nut syrup
Estimated Nutritional Information (Venti): 350 calories, 63g sugar, 120mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: Make it a dirty toffee nut chai tea latte with a shot of espresso. Switch to your preferred milk option.
9. Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate
You can toss your diet to the wind with this beverage, but it’s the holiday season. Or close to it. Or maybe you’re only starting your diet on Monday. There must be a reason to justify this treat. On a freezing winter day, there’s nothing like a steaming cup of hot chocolate to keep the goosebumps and shivers away. And to take it to the next level, add some salted caramel flavoring to the mix!
The Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate is on the regular menu, so it’s easy to order. This hot, comfort drink contains the following:
- Steamed milk
- 4 pumps Mocha sauce
- 4 pumps Toffee nut syrup
- Whipped cream on top
- Caramel drizzle
Nutritional Information (Grande): 460 calories, 59g sugar, 25mg caffeine
Tips for modifying:To cut calories use nonfat milk or non-dairy options. Ask for less syrup, as this is a very sweet treat. You can also add some espresso shots to counteract the sweetness.
8. Iced Toffee Mocha Macchiato
Here’s a regular menu treat for that sweltering day when your sweet tooth is throwing a tantrum to be indulged. You don’t have the patience to search for fancy secret menu options to control the cravings. The Iced Toffee Mocha Macchiato will do the job for you.
It’s a combination of everyone’s favorite flavors: toffee, chocolate, and coffee. What could be better than that? Your Iced Toffee Mocha Macchiato is a blend of the following ingredients:
- 2% Milk
- 2 – 3 pumps caramel syrup
- 2 – 3 pumps toffee nut syrup
- 2 shots of espresso
- Simple syrup
- Served over ice
- Top with mocha drizzle
Nutritional Information (Grande): 190 calories, 27g sugar, 150mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: Top it with whipped cream before adding the mocha drizzle for a richer, creamier drink. Add more shots of espresso for a more potent caffeine boost.
7. The Roasted Chestnut
Roasted chestnuts taste like holidays, and although this isn’t a seasonal holiday beverage, few flavors shout “Christmas” like roasted chestnuts. It conjures up images of log cabins in snowy mountain ranges with crackling fires.
It’s not a seasonal Christmas drink, so we categorize it as a secret menu drink. The advantage of secret menu drinks is that you can order them throughout the year. Although the Roasted Chestnut will undoubtedly get any last-minute gift shoppers into the Christmas spirit with its sweet, subtly spiced flavor.
So, how do you order this delightful treat? Here is the recipe:
- Ask for a Hazelnut Macchiato, consisting of 2 espresso shots, 3-4 pumps of vanilla syrup, steamed milk, and hazelnut drizzle
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, 2 for venti)
- Add Hazelnut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, 2 for venti)
- Ask for white chocolate mocha syrup (1/2 pump for tall and grande, 1 for venti)
- Whipped cream on top with hazelnut drizzle
Estimated Nutritional Information (Grande): 280 calories, 52g sugar, 150mg caffeine
This estimation was based on the nutritional information of a Hazelnut Macchiato and adding extra calories and sugar for the additional syrups.
Tips for modifying: Add more espresso shots for an extra caffeine kick. Select the milk of your choice. Ask for hazelnut syrup to reduce the sweetness.
6. Vanilla Pumpkin Nut Latte
Starbucks carries several pumpkin spice items on its fall menu, and this secret menu drink is one of the best. It tastes like falling leaves and sweet spicey flavors on the cool breeze. You can enjoy it hot or cold, and though it may sound like too many flavors in one beverage, each compliments the other without any overwhelming clashes.
To order a Vanilla Pumpkin Nut Latte, ask your barista for the following:
- A Pumpkin Spice Latte, made with pumpkin spice sauce, milk, and espresso, with whipped cream and pumpkin spice sprinkled on top.
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 1.5 for grande, and 2 for venti)
- Vanilla syrup (1 pump for tall and grande, 1.5 for venti)
Estimated Nutritional Information (Grande): 430 calories, 60g sugar, 150mg caffeine
The estimation was based on the nutritional information of a Pumpkin Spice Latte with the additional syrups.
Tips for modifying: Choose one of the vegan milk options if you don’t consume dairy. Use nonfat milk to bring the calorie count down.
5. Chunky Monkey Frappuccino
Ben and Jerry meet Starbucks in this secret menu Frappuccino. The popular and scrumptious ice-cream flavor of banana, walnuts, and chocolate is now immortalized in a Frappuccino. These flavors pair so well together! This treat works out best as a venti serving. Ask your barista to follow this recipe for a Chunky Monkey:
- Start with a Crème based Frappuccino, a blend of milk and ice
- Add a whole banana
- 2 scoops vanilla bean powder
- 2 pumps hazelnut syrup
- 2 pumps toffee nut syrup
- 2 pumps mocha syrup
- Add light mocha and caramel drizzle on top
This treat is loaded with calories and sugar, so it’s probably best to only have it once in a blue moon. Alternatively, share it with someone special. That way, you only take in half the calories, but you enjoy all the flavor and some great company.
Estimated Nutritional Information (Venti): Approximately 650 calories, 98g sugar, 0mg caffeine
The estimation was based on the nutritional information for a Venti Vanilla Bean Crème Frappuccino with the additional ingredients.
Tips for modifying: Ask for less syrup to decrease the calories of this loaded drink, or substitute one of the syrups with sugar-free vanilla syrup. Add some espresso shots if you need a caffeine kick.
4. Caramel Cocoa Cluster Frappuccino
The Caramel Cocoa Cluster Frappuccino will hit the spot when you’ve spent the day on the beach. This regular menu item is an explosion of chocolate, caramel, and nuts, and it’s a perfect summer vacation indulgence. There is no better combination, as seen by the number of fancy beverages made with these ingredients.
To make this iced favorite, Starbucks blends the following ingredients:
- Ice
- Milk
- 3 pumps Frappuccino syrup
- 2 pumps toffee nut syrup
- Whipped cream topping
- Mocha Drizzle
Nutritional Information (Grande): 440 calories, 68g sugar, 90mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: Add some Java chips to your drink for some extra crunch. If you want to reduce the calorie count, use nonfat milk and decrease the pumps of syrup.
3. Caramel Brûlée Latte
The Caramel Brûlée Latte is a seasonal item on the regular menu. It’s a favorite winter beverage, with its decadent dessert flavor and crunchy caramel topping reminiscent of the scorched, crispy surface of the original Crème Brûlée dessert.
Starbucks makes the seasonal beverage with its signature espresso, steamed milk, and caramel brûlée sauce and adds whipped cream and caramel brûlée bits on top.
Except for the caramel brûlée crunchy bits, an almost identical flavor can be captured in a secret menu drink by asking the barista to make this beverage with the following ingredients:
- A traditional latte
- Add white mocha syrup (1 pump for tall, 2 for grande, and 3 for venti)
- Add toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 2 for grande, and 3 for venti)
Before you know it, this tasty latte will be back on the menu, and you can enjoy the bona fide Caramel Brûlée Latte in its truest form, including crunchy bits.
Nutritional Information (Grande): 410 calories, 48g sugar, 150mg caffeine
Tips for modifying: To add more coffee flavor, increase your espresso shots. Sprinkle some cinnamon powder for a subtle, spicey finish.
2. Coffee Cake Frappuccino
Don’t you just love going out for coffee and cake and spending time chatting with friends? It’s a great idea, but then reality hits, and you know there’s no time for chatty coffee dates. The Coffee Cake Frappuccino is the next best thing, then. Grab your bestie, order this secret menu treat, and chat while you’re in the queue before you go back to work.
If your eyes have ever tried the Classic Coffee Cake topped with cinnamon streusels, this will be the flavor that pulls through in your Frappuccino. To order your coffee date in a cup, ask for the following:
- Order a Coffee Frappuccino, a simple blend of coffee, milk, and ice
- With Cinnamon Dolce syrup (1 pump for tall, 2 for grande, and 3 for venti)
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 2 for grande, and 3 for venti)
- Vanilla syrup (1/2 pump for tall and grande, 1 for venti) – this step is optional
- Add whipped cream and cinnamon dolce topping for the final layer
Estimated Nutritional Information (Grande): 332 calories, 68g sugar, 155mg caffeine
The estimation uses the information from an Espresso Frappuccino and includes the extra calories and sugar from the whipped cream topping and additional syrups.
Tips to modify: Exchange milk options if you prefer plant-based milk. Nonfat milk will bring the calorie count down. Add extra shots of espresso for flavor.
1. Caramel And Nut Chocolate Bar Frappuccino
It’s official; this is our all-time favorite! If you’re a chocoholic, having an icy chocolate bar in a cup is just the ticket on a balmy summer’s day. This secret menu drink will have you returning daily to your nearest Starbucks store. But watch out; it’s a high-calorie addiction!
The base drink is a Java Chip Frappuccino, a blend of coffee, milk, ice, and mocha sauce, topped with whipped cream and mocha sauce. To order the upgraded version, the Caramel and Nut Chocolate Bar Frappuccino, ask for the following:
- A Java Chip Frappuccino, consisting of ice, milk, coffee, Java chips, and mocha sauce
- Toffee nut syrup (1 pump for tall, 2 for grande, and 3 for venti)
- Caramel drizzle inside the cup and atop the whipped cream
Estimated Nutritional Information (Grande): 480 calories, 69g sugar, 105mg caffeine
The estimated calories and sugar were based on the Java Chip Frappuccino’s nutritional information and adding the extra syrups.
Tips for modifying: Reduce the syrups and use nonfat milk for less sugar and calories.
Does Starbucks Have Toffee Nut Syrup All Year?
Starbucks Toffee Nut drinks are seasonal on the regular menu, but the syrup is available all year round. This means you are free to create your favorite toffee nut beverages anytime, as long as you have the secret menu recipe for your barista.
Conclusion
Starbucks Toffee Nut is a popular flavor, often associated with the winter holidays. It has a sweet, nutty taste that pairs well with so many different drinks, including coffees, hot chocolates, Frappuccinos, and more. Yes, they are high in calories and sugar, but there are ways to decrease that. Or you could just fast for the rest of the day! Either way, Starbucks Toffee Nut is worth a shot!
Resources
https://www.starbucks.com/menu/
https://www.delish.com/food/g4173/starbucks-secret-menu-frappuccinos/
https://trulyexperiences.com/blog/starbucks-secret-menu-hack/