Thinking of Trying Mayo in Coffee? Here’s How to Make It

Last Updated on February 2, 2023 by brewthatcoffee

Who would’ve thought you could add mayonnaise to coffee? The idea isn’t too far-fetched, given that our curious nature has a way of leading us on wild and adventurous culinary journeys.

While we occasionally come across true gems that delight even the most skeptical taste buds, our wild culinary adventures can cause quite a stir, especially on social media. Putting mayo in coffee is one of those trends that spark such divided debates online.

Some people swear by mayonnaise coffee, while others find it bizarre. People have suggested adding mayo to coffee over the years, but two scenarios provoked the most heated debates.

One scenario was when Hellmann’s Mayonnaise suggested putting mayonnaise in coffee in a Twitter post. The other was when CBS Sports posted a video of Kentucky quarterback Will Levis demonstrating how he adds mayo to coffee.

Whatever piqued your curiosity for mayo coffee doesn’t matter. Let’s explore why some athletes like it, how to prepare it, and how it tastes. The final verdict on the taste is yours, though!

Why Some Athletes Drink It

While the initial idea to put mayo in coffee is often motivated by curiosity, some athletes continue to consume it for different reasons. Here are the top three ones:

Extra Calories

Athletes often require more calories to provide their bodies with the energy needed for intense physical activity during practice and competition. Some are always on the lookout for new ways to meet their calorie needs, and mayo may provide an extra boost of calories since it’s high in fat.

Great for the Keto Diet

Mayonnaise is high in fat and low in carbohydrates. Since a keto diet emphasizes high fat and low carbohydrate intake, it’s easy to see why athletes following a ketogenic diet would love this debatable concoction.

The combination of mayonnaise and coffee may also help to keep athletes full and satisfied, making it a good way to avoid snacking. The drink might also be a snack. 

But does adding fat to the beverage make sense? If you’re asking yourself this question, then you’ve probably never heard of Bulletproof coffee, which involves adding butter to coffee. It also started with divided opinions, much like mayo in coffee, but it’s now a trend.

Some Actually Like the Taste of It

While mayonnaise coffee may not be for everyone, some athletes actually enjoy the taste and use it in place of cream. Maybe the creamy nature of mayo enhances the flavor of coffee? 

So what does mayo in coffee taste like? We’ll cover more on that later and try to describe the flavor well. However, keep in mind that the same food item may taste differently to different people because of our DNA.

Coffee Mayonnaise Recipe

Now that you’re feeling adventurous and up for a challenge, it’s time to learn how to make coffee with mayonnaise. It’s an easy recipe as you’ll see below.

Equipment

• Coffee maker
• Whisk
• Spoon
• Cup
• Milk frother or blender

Ingredients

• 1 cup of hot coffee
• 1 tablespoon of mayonnaise

Instructions

We’ll provide two recipe variations, and you’ll choose the best one for you. The difference is in how you combine the two ingredients, which can influence the result.

For the first one, you’ll use a milk frother or a small blender to achieve a smooth consistency. Here’s how you do it:

• Brew a cup of coffee as you normally do
• Add it to a milk frother or blender
• Add one tablespoon of mayo to the milk frother
• Blend the ingredients
• Serve yourself and take a sip 

If you don’t like the blending option, try this one:

• Prepare a cup of coffee
• Add it to a bowl
• Put one tablespoon of mayo in the bowl
• Whisk the ingredients until smooth
• Pour yourself the creamy drink

What It Tastes Like

Mayo in coffee is exactly what it sounds like: a mixture of coffee and mayonnaise. So the taste is creamy and has some mayo flavor. This means you might find it unappealing if you don’t like mayo. 

Notably, the taste can vary based on certain factors like the mayo type used, the amount of coffee and mayo, and recipes. If you add too much mayo, it’ll overcome the taste of coffee. Some fans of this drink suggest that putting mayo on cold brew coffee tastes better than hot coffee.

Tips for Preparing Coffee Mayonnaise

If you want to make a good verdict on the taste of mayo coffee, you should keep a few things in mind. If you follow these tips, you might enjoy the drink. 

• Start with a small amount of mayonnaise, such as a teaspoon for a cup of coffee. You can increase it gradually to your desired taste
• Use lemon-based mayo instead of vinegar-based
• Prepare your mayo at home, if possible, or buy one with minimal ingredients
• Whisk or blend until you have a smooth consistency
• Try the recipes using cold-brew coffee

If you don’t mind the taste of mayo, take the leap and satisfy your curiosity with a cup of mayo coffee. Who knows, it might just become your new favorite drink! And if you don’t like it, you don’t need to go past the first sip.

Mayo in Coffee FAQs

What Football Player Puts Mayonnaise in His Coffee?

Kentucky quarterback Will Levis is a well-known footballer who puts mayonnaise in his coffee.

Why Does Will Levis Put Mayo in His Coffee?

Will Levis puts mayo in his coffee sometimes because he likes it. He started the habit out of curiosity when having breakfast with his girlfriend. He asked why there was mayonnaise on the table, and she suggested jokingly that maybe some people add it to coffee. 

He knew it was a joke but thought, why not test it out?